DE | EN
Sitemap | Impressum
web2.0 Diaspora Vimeo taz We at Mastodon A-FsA Song RSS Twitter Youtube Tumblr Flickr Wikipedia Donation Facebook Bitmessage BlueSky Tor-Netzwerk https-everywhere
17.11.2026 Können die Geheimdienste jetzt alles?

Appeal to Members of Parliament Falls on Deaf Ears

It was not in vain that the Committee for Fundamental Rights and Democracy, the Republican Lawyers’ Association (RAV), and the Association of Democratic Lawyers (VDJ) wrote an open letter to the members of the German Bundestag regarding the planned reform of the German intelligence services — a letter that has since been endorsed by 28 additional NGOs. Even though the federal government managed to secure a parliamentary majority for this on November 13, the debate over this blow to the separation principle (established by the Allies in 1948) will not cease.

Based on the experiences with the Gestapo, it should be prevented forever that the police and intelligence services cooperate under a single leadership, and the work of the intelligence services should be subject to parliamentary oversight.

Erosion of the principle of separation

The open letter, however, states: The draft goes far beyond the adjustment to intelligence service law required by the Federal Constitutional Court with regard to the thresholds for intervention by the intelligence services. The Federal Constitutional Court justified the constitutionality of the intelligence services on the grounds that, while they have more far-reaching powers to collect data, they do not have police powers to conduct interventions (see Federal Constitutional Court, judgment of April 26, 2022 – 1 BvR 1619/17, BVerfGE 162, 1, paras. 154–156).

In particular, intelligence services must not be permitted to engage in the following activities:

  • Under the draft bill, the intelligence services will be permitted to sabotage IT systems in the future.
  • They are to be able to interfere with all objects, including digital data sets, software, digital infrastructures, etc.
  • The BfV is to be authorized to take measures that even the police are not permitted to carry out.
  • The BND is granted unlimited jurisdiction. The draft bill expands the BND’s domestic operations in several ways. This would also allow for the use of physical force.
  • Extensive access to video surveillance of public spaces — by both government and private entities (even in real time) — the use of publicly accessible image and video data for biometric matching, and comprehensive automated analysis of large datasets — including through the use of artificial intelligence — are to be permitted, contrary to the EU AI Act.
  • The BND and BfV are even supposed to be able to make operational decisions independently and automatically trigger countermeasures when defending against cyberattacks.
  • Young people can be recruited as informants — a nod to the old days of the IMs.
  • There is to be a “special determination case” independent of a defense or crisis situation, which the federal government can secretly declare — with the approval of the Parliamentary Oversight Committee — without the knowledge of the Bundestag (Section 125(3) of the Draft BND Act).

The open letter concludes by stating: Vote against this bill!
Instead, implement the requirements of the Federal Constitutional Court without expanding the powers of the BND and BfV at the expense of fundamental rights, the rule of law, and democratic oversight.


A Glimpse into Future Practice?

For the first time in 18 years, we received a letter to the editor yesterday regarding one of our TV recommendations (RFT) for tonight at 10:30 p.m. “Murderers Preferred—How the BND Recruited Nazi Criminals”. In it, a reader of our site comments on last Friday’s episode of "SOKO Leipzig" as follows:
“That’s right — last Friday’s episode of "SOKO Leipzig" showed exactly that: the BND removes the murderer — who was finally apprehended after 90 minutes — from criminal prosecution, much to the dismay of the police detectives, because he might be better suited as an agent against Russia.
And this is happening today — not in the 1950s!”

“Murderer given preferential treatment” is indeed true, because after watching the episode, we learned that the BND agent from Berlin even planted the murder weapon in an innocent person’s car in a way that looked convincing to the detectives.

It is precisely this fabrication of evidence — which is particularly easy in the digital realm — that the open letter criticizes. Reality is created at will, and if you get caught, you simply stand up during the interrogation — just like the agent did — and drive back to Berlin. Good thing it was just a movie so far...


P.S. Coincidentally, after 18 months of 100% reliable operation, our server crashed twice today of all days. The probability of that happening is 1 in 547. And the bill is still not valid and has to pass the Bundesrat. Let’s stop it!

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)

Read more https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/bundestag-beschliesst-geheimdienst-reform-geheimpolizei-bnd-bfv-gefahren
and the Open Letter https://www.grundrechtekomitee.de/details/trennungsgebot-erhalten-kontrolle-staerken-ihre-stimme-gegen-die-nachrichtendienstreform-offener-brief-von-28-organisationen-an-die-abgeordneten-des-deutschen-bundestages


Category[21]: Unsere Themen in der Presse Short-Link to this page: a-fsa.de/e/3SZ
Link to this page: https://www.a-fsa.de/de/articles/9721-20261117-koennen-die-geheimdienste-jetzt-alles.html
Link with Tor: http://a6pdp5vmmw4zm5tifrc3qo2pyz7mvnk4zzimpesnckvzinubzmioddad.onion/de/articles/9721-20261117-koennen-die-geheimdienste-jetzt-alles.html
Tags: #Nachrichtendienste #Geheimdienste #BND #BfV #Trennungsgebot #Lauschangriff #Überwachung #Vorratsdatenspeicherung #Videoüberwachung #Rasterfahndung #Cyberwar #Hacking #Verhaltensänderung #Datenbanken #unverhältnismäßig
Created: 2026-11-17 08:02:39


Leave a Comment

For further confidential communication, we recommend that you include a reference to a secure messenger, such as Session, Bitmessage, or similar, below the comment text.

To prevent the use of this form by spam robots, please enter the portrayed character set in the left picture below into the right field.

CC License   Member in the European Civil Liberties Network   Bundesfreiwilligendienst   We don't store user data   World Beyond War   No use of JavaScript